Can a paper be rejected after minor revision

Author: zzaa

August undefined, 2024

WebMay 29, 2024 · No, minor revision doesn't mean accepted with minor revisions. Strictly speaking, for truly minor revisions, it's possible that the editor accepts your paper and … WebAnswer (1 of 6): This happened to me once, though I was given a notional reason that they rejected if not happy after two rounds of reviews. In fact, I learnt that the reviewers were happy with the final version, and surprised to hear that it had been rejected. It went to another, but less highl...

Peer Review Process Wiley

WebNov 21, 2024 · Otherwise, the Associate Editor (AE) or Managing Editor (ME) – basically, whoever is handling your paper – is happy to look at the minor revisions and give the clearance (acceptance decision) themselves. In some cases, by Under Review, the journal may mean either the second peer review or the second AE/ME review. WebI had papers that was accepted without revision, papers that was rejected in 24 hours, and papers that was accepted after 4 years times and after more than 20 revise and reject process. high regency orlando

Journal Said “Major Revisions” Needed? Here’s What to Do

WebAug 22, 2024 · For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly between 80-90%. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it just seems downright unfair to reject the paper. But, there can be a resignation to accept an okay paper at this point too. Web5. After saving the CAD files to PDF format, ensure that no ‘comments’ or ‘editable content’ exists in the file (embedded hyperlinks are acceptable. ) 6. Paper plans scanned to PDF format are acceptable, but should be clearly legible and follow the same rules above. 7. Ensure the file name meets the naming recommendations noted above. WebHappy to share CPS-GUARD, our latest paper published in the flagship Computers & Security Journal! CPS-GUARD deals with the primary problem of detecting… high register tone

The Use of Neurofeedback in Sports Training: Systematic Review

Can I resubmit a manuscript that has been rewritten and …

WebDec 19, 2024 · 1 Answer to this question. Answer: Once a revised paper is submitted, the editor can choose to send it for another round of peer review or review it himself/herself. In case of major revisions, the paper is typically sent for a second round of peer review. however, for minor revisions, the editor often does not feel the need to send the paper ... how many calories in a beef bouillon cubeWebJun 12, 2024 · Can a paper get rejected after a major revision? The only stage where an editorial decision will be warranted is for minor or stylistic, cosmetic or maybe adding a few additional references. This would correspond to all reviewers suggesting that the paper be accepted with minor revisions. high rehab kent ct

"WebEven the best papers could sometimes receive a major revision or rejection after an initial minor revision request. It all depends on the editor to adjudge the comments base on the merit of the paper. " - Can a paper be rejected after minor revision

Can a paper be rejected after minor revision

Is peer review just a crapshoot? - Elsevier Connect

WebMay 31, 2024 · Minor revision means that your paper accepted by about 70 % but not final acceptance until you fix further comments. Can a paper get rejected after a minor … WebSep 12, 2012 · 6. It's simply a small extension of a different paper, often from the same authors. Findings are incremental and do not advance the field. The work is clearly part of a larger study, chopped up to make as many articles as possible. 7. It's incomprehensible. The language, structure, or figures are so poor that the merit can't be assessed.

Did you know?

WebSep 23, 2015 · Is it common for a journal to reject a paper after previously accepting it? When a paper of mine was first reviewed, one of the reviewers was okay with the paper and the other one requested minor revisions. The journal clearly said that the paper was … Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack … WebApr 9, 2024 · Accept with minor revisions ... If the decision involves revision for the author, the specific changes that are required should be clearly stated in the decision letter and …

WebMay 20, 2015 · If a paper is officially rejected with invited resubmission, and a new version is resubmitted with revisions, then this dramatically cuts down on the time-between-submission-and-acceptance metric. ... Minor Revision=6% Major Revision=20.7% Reject/Resubmit=21.6% (Includes decisons made by EIC+SE not to send to referees) … WebAt the 1st review, the referees' have written positive statement. One of the referee suggested minor revision, while the other suggested major revision. I have revised the paper according to the referees' comments. Recently. I have received minor comments (only a few text corrections) from the referee who suggested major revision at the 1st …

WebResponse: A minor revision often implies that there are a limited number of changes that are needed to improve the manuscript for publication. Depending on the extent of the … WebOct 23, 2024 · What does a dissertation mean in revision? Will the paper be rejected after minor revisions? What does revised status mean? Do minor revisions imply acceptance? small version means Your paper is accepted about 70% but won’t be accepted until you fix the additional feedback. Timing varies by journal, but is within a month.

WebApr 12, 2024 · Acknowledge the receipt. The first thing you should do after submitting your revised paper is to acknowledge the receipt of your submission by the journal. This is a simple but courteous gesture ...

WebMay 30, 2024 · The reasons for a paper being rejected once it has been reviewed fall mainly into two categories: (1) problems with the research; and (2) problems with the writing/presentation of the paper. A paper may be rejected because of problems with the research on which it is based. how many calories in a beetWeb1. No, minor revision doesn't mean accepted with minor revisions. Strictly speaking, for truly minor revisions, it's possible that the editor accepts your paper and leaves you to … high reinforcing n339WebMar 9, 2024 · Situation 1: Accept with Minor Revision. Example, “The paper is well written, presents new matter, and can be published with minor revisions: ... We hope the articles in this series have better prepared you for dealing with journal revision or rejection. Common Manuscript Errors. Rate this article. Cancel Reply. You must be logged in to post ... high rehabWebThe one deciding upon the acceptance or rejection of your paper is the editor, not the reviewers. In an extreme example, you do not need to fear that your paper is rejected due to a review saying nothing but: I recommend to reject this paper because of fish. The editor would just blacklist the reviewer and request another one. how many calories in a beef taquitoWebMay 7, 2024 · It took almost 8 months.According to the reviewer, the paper did not contain the right message and needed a significant overhaul to be published. I fully respect the … how many calories in a batchelors cup a soupWebJan 9, 2024 · APESM rejects between 35 and 40% of submitted manuscripts without sending them to reviewers, some because their subject matter is outside of the scope of APESM. Another 30% or so are rejected after review . The authors of rejected manuscripts are provided with the reasons and I think it instructive to summarise and … how many calories in a berry smoothieWebOne reviewer recommended a minor revision with detailed feedback. ... shallow review with no valuable feedback and rejected the paper. This is how the third reviewer's review goes as follows ... high reins hexham